Should you reupholster or replace your sofa?

Start with the problem you want to solve. A sofa with a worn cover needs a different assessment from one with loose joints and sagging seats. There is no universal fraction of a new sofa’s price that makes the decision for every piece.

Inspect three separate layers

• Cover: stains, tears, seam damage or an unwanted color. New fabric alone does not restore missing seat support.
• Filling and suspension: ask the upholsterer to assess cushion inserts, webbing and springs separately.
• Frame and mechanisms: establish what can be repaired and which work remains uncertain until inspection.

Compare two complete plans

1. List what you want to keep: the size, shape, comfort or sentimental value. Then list the problems that must change.
2. Request an inspection and itemized repair estimate, identifying unknowns.
3. Choose a specific replacement for comparison. Include fit, doorway clearance, delivery, assembly and removal of the old sofa.
4. Plan for time without the furniture and any access difficulties. Ask who handles transport.
5. Decide on the whole outcome rather than the original purchase price or age alone.

Antiques and mechanisms need an appropriate specialist

Before stripping an antique or modifying a powered seat, discuss what must be preserved and who is equipped to do the work. Restoration, recovery and a full rebuild can have different goals. Keep photos and the agreed specification so the result can be checked against the brief.